C-cgen-side nullable folding landed in f4efaac. This commit catches
the selfhost cgen up so a wwstage-compiled binary produces the same
ABI for `(*T | void)`.
- cgenutil: isnullabletype(), nullableptrtag() helpers shaped to
the selfhost cgen's AST-only world view (it doesn't carry a Type
with a .nullable flag — it walks N_TTAGGED node lists). slotsize
returns 8 for nullable.
- cgenexpr cgmatch: nullable arm uses pointer-vs-null discriminator
and binds only the *T case (void has size 0).
- cgenstmt cglet: nullable target spills only AX (no tag word, no
value-word DX/CX).
- cgenstmt cgreturn: nullable return passes AX through with no
shuffle; bare `return;` emits AX = 0 (void encoding).
Verified end-to-end: a fn returning `(*i32 | void)` compiled by the
wwstage cgen produces the same exit code as the C-cgen build. The
995 fixed-point gate stays green — no selfhost source uses nullable
yet, so the existing tagged paths are still byte-identical.
Selfhost parser (lib/ww/parse/expr.ww) recognises postfix `?` and
`!` at the same level as `as`/`is`/`:`. Selfhost cgen
(selfhost/cmd/wcc/cgenexpr.ww) emits matching code: cmp AX against
the success tag (0 in legacy mode), branch over the propagate /
abort path, then unwrap (DX → AX, CX → BX for str). Mirrors the C
cgen but without the tag-remap loop — none of the selfhost code
that uses `?` today needs cross-shape remapping.
lib/ww/lex/lex.ww \\x escape handling switched from 5-line match
blocks to one-liners: ascii.digitval(c: rune)!. Both digits are
already validated by isxdigit above; the void variant is
unreachable, so `!` collapses correctly. 995 fixed-point gate
verifies the selfhost cgen produces the same `!` codegen as C cgen.
Final piece of the os module graduation: the three try* wrappers
move off the (T | str) placeholder shape. `oserror` becomes a real
Hare-style error type (`!i64` instead of plain `i64`), so it's
picked up by ?-propagation as the error half without callers having
to name it.
tryread: (i64 | oserror) was (i64 | str)
trywrite: (i64 | oserror) was (i64 | str)
tryopen: (i32 | oserror) was (i32 | str)
Callsites updated: wwdump uses tryopen; the e2e trywrite probe
matches on os.oserror and validates -EBADF for a bad fd (-9 instead
of the old "write failed" string length).
selfhost/test/smoke.ww switched to raw os.open(2) instead of
os.tryopen for probe 7 — same reason as the os.readall switch in
the prior commit: probe 6 in 990_selfhost compiles smoke.ww
standalone, and cross-module type refs like `os.oserror` don't
resolve in that mode.
A type prefixed with `!` is flagged as an error variant. When any
variant in a tagged union carries the flag, `?` propagation uses
those (and only those) as the error subset; the unflagged variant
is the success type. The legacy "first variant = success" rule still
applies when no `!`-flag is present, so existing code keeps working.
- TK_NOT in parsetype → N_TBANG wrapper (lhs = inner type expr).
Appended to Nkind tail for wwdump-diff byte stability.
- resolve_type N_TBANG: wraps primitives in a fresh Type copy so the
iserror bit doesn't taint shared globals like ty_str/ty_i32; flips
the bit in place on NAMED (already unique per alias decl).
- Type.iserror; type_named and typedecl inherit it from under.
- New check.c helpers: tagged_has_errflag, tagged_is_error_variant,
tagged_success_type. N_TRYPROP uses them to find the error subset
and verify each error variant is propagatable to the enclosing
return.
- cgen mirrors with cg_tagged_success_tag + cg_variant_is_error.
`?` compares AX against the success tag (no longer always 0) and
remaps each error variant's tag for the enclosing fn. `!` aborts
on any non-success tag.
strconv.invalid and strconv.overflow now use `!`-flagged shape
(`!i32` and `!void`) — visible signal in the API surface that they
are error types, matching Hare. The (i64 | invalid | overflow)
return shape and behavior are unchanged for callers; their match
arms still bind the same way.
Selfhost: lib/ww/parse/parse.ww recognises `!T` and emits N_TBANG.
The selfhost typechecker and cgen ignore the flag — none of the
selfhost sources use `!`, so byte-identity gates are unaffected.
The selfhost mirror catches up when there's a source using it.
`type oserror = i64` carries -errno (Hare's errors::errno-shaped
named-i64). The three convenience wrappers move off the i64 = -1
sentinel and onto the tagged-union surface.
Callers updated across the selfhost (wwdump, w6c, w6a, w6l, ww
driver). The slurp paths in w6c/w6a/w6l/wwdump now match on the
filesize and readall results; the ELF-emitting writeall sites in
w6a/obj.ww are wrapped through two small local helpers (`wrn` for
"wrote N bytes ok?", `wrdrop` for fire-and-forget) so the existing
11-callsite write loop stays readable.
selfhost/test/smoke.ww kept using raw os.read instead of
os.readall: the 990 cgen-match probe compiles smoke.ww standalone
(no `use` expansion), and cross-module type references like
`os.oserror` can't be resolved in that mode.
Two selfhost-side gaps surfaced and got plugged:
- lib/ww/parse/parse.ww parsetype now collapses dotted type names
(`pkg.Type` → single N_TNAME with the joined string), mirroring C
parsetype's dotted-path loop. Local `joindotted` helper because
there's no arena-based string-concat in the selfhost lib yet.
- selfhost/cmd/wcc/check.ww name-resolver applies the dotted-prefix
rule from cmd/wcc/check.c's resolve_typename: split at the last
dot, look up the head as a `use` import, then the leaf as a type.
ascii.digitval returns (i32 | void) instead of an i32 -1 sentinel.
Two callers updated to match-on the result (lib/ww/lex/lex.ww escape
parse, selfhost/test/smoke.ww probe 6).
`!` would have been more idiomatic at both call sites — both have
verified isxdigit beforehand — but the selfhost parser doesn't yet
recognize postfix `!`/`?`, so using them in bootstrap-bound code
breaks the 993/995 byte-identity gates. Match is fine for now.
Selfhost cgen follow-on for the 8-byte-rounded tagged-union ABI
(landed in 1e2f55a for the C side):
- cgenutil.slotsize: tagged size = 8 (tag) + max(payload), padded to
8-byte multiple. Was hardcoded 24.
- cgendecl prologue: spill size/8 arg registers, not always 3.
- cgenstmt cglet tagged-call path: spill the CX value-word only when
the slot is >16 bytes.
All three were emitting 3-register patterns appropriate to (T | str)
sized unions and overflowing the new 16-byte (i32 | void) slots.
`type invalid = i32` (payload: byte index of first bad rune; mirrors
Hare's strconv::invalid = !size) and `type overflow = void` (Hare's
overflow = !void). stoi64/stou64 now return these instead of the
str-error placeholder. atoi64 dropped — lib/CLAUDE.md says graduate
in one go, don't keep both shapes around.
To produce the void variant payload, `void` is now a real
expression literal (TK_VOID kw, N_VOIDLIT). It evaluates to ty_void;
codegen emits MOVQ $0, AX. Both kinds are appended at the tail of
their enums to keep prior numeric values byte-stable for the
wwdump-diff fixtures.
check_file reorder: USE declarations are now installed in pass 1
alongside the type-decl placeholders so dotted type references
(`strconv.invalid` from a typedecl body) resolve. DEF/FN/LET silently
overwrite a USE-occupied slot — matches the old behavior where USE
silently no-op'd when a same-name fn/def existed (the conflict
manifested in selfhost main.combined.ww at `use parse;` colliding
with `export fn parse(a)`).
selfhost mirror: lib/ww/lex/tok.ww kwtab+name; lib/ww/ast.ww
N_VOIDLIT def+print; lib/ww/parse/{expr,parse}.ww TK_VOID handling;
selfhost/cmd/wcc/cgenexpr.ww N_VOIDLIT codegen.
`e is T` returns bool (variant tag == T's index); `e as T` unwraps
to T or exit(1) on mismatch. Postfix, same precedence as `:` cast.
TK_IS / N_TYPETEST / N_TYPEASSERT appended at the tail of their
enums so every prior numeric value stays unchanged — the
990_selfhost wwdump-diff stays byte-clean.
Cgen mirrors the match-case slot-based load (tag at +0, value at
+8/+16), so an N_IDENT tagged-union local works just like a
match scrutinee. Selfhost cgen inlines the slot resolution
because the wwstage cgen drops sign bits on `*i32` output
parameters in this position.
Renames `errors.is` -> `errors.equal` (the only naming collision;
the existing comment already noted it shared shape with
strings.equal/bytes.equal).
Plan 9-style w-prefix on the per-arch tools, disambiguating from the
real Plan 9 6c/6a/6l in ref/plan9front/:
cmd/wwc/ → cmd/wcc/ libwwc.a → libwcc.a
cmd/6{c,a,l} → cmd/w6{c,a,l} binary names too
test/wwc/ → test/wcc/ 6 test files w/ w6 prefix
selfhost/cmd mirror in lockstep
bootstrap/amd64/{w6c,w6a,w6l} snapshot binaries (gitignored)
WW_6{C,A,L} → WW_W6{C,A,L} env-var overrides
Plan 9 source-tree refs ("Plan 9 6c shape", ref/plan9front/, etc.)
preserved. Hare-style driver, both C and ww sides:
ww test [path] discover *_test.ww in a directory module, run
each; single-file mode for `ww test foo.ww`
Module-by-name `ww build foo` resolves to foo.ww or foo/foo.ww
via search path (cwd : -I dirs : $WW_LIB)
Default-to-cwd `ww build` / `ww test` build the cwd module
Run pass-through `ww run path arg1 arg2` reaches the program
lib/os: getcwd (79) and getdents64 (217) syscalls power `.` resolution
and directory enumeration on the ww side.
Makefile: wwstage tool deps now include lib/os/os.ww (+ lib/strconv
for wwdump_ww) so lib/* edits force their rebuild instead of leaving
stale binaries — surfaced when test 995 first failed against a stale
w6c_ww built before the lib/os additions.
Test 993 byte-identical parity gate (C-side ww vs ww-side ww_ww on a
build corpus) stays green; all 19 tests pass.
Ports cmd/6l/{dyn,dynout}.c into selfhost/cmd/6l/{dyn,dynout}.ww:
ET_DYN .so loading + PT_INTERP/PT_DYNAMIC ELF emission with .rela.plt,
.gnu.version_r, BIND_NOW. lsym grows dyn fields; pass.ww promotes
undefs to dyn; out.ww dispatches; main.ww takes -L/-l. The ww driver
forwards -L/-l to 6l_ww so 'ww_ww build snake.ww -L /usr/lib -l ncurses
-l c' runs without cc.
Test 996 pins byte-identical output to C-6l on snake.
'make bootstrap' gains a fourth stage with cmp ww3 == ww4, proving
ww3 is byte-stable when used as a compiler — not just a coincidental
two-stage equilibrium.
Four wwstage 6c cgen quirks surfaced and are documented in dynout.ww's
header (two-level field-write through a pointer field, (scalar, str)
tuple returns, def : str, ≤6 arg calling convention).
Drives ww_ww (which already shells to 6c_ww/6a_ww/6l_ww) over each
wwstage tool's source and diffs the resulting binary against the
cstage-built canonical in $BIN. A green run means the toolchain
can recompile itself end-to-end without invoking cc, modulo the
cold-start binary that brings the wwstage into existence.
Stricter than `make bootstrap`: that loop pins wwdump's cgen
self-stabilising; this pins all five wwstage tools (6c, 6a, 6l,
ww, wwdump) round-tripping through the wwstage pipeline.
The .combined.ww refreshes are the expander picking up the
parser/cgen changes from the prior commit. selfhost/cmd/6c/
gains its main.combined.ww for the first time — 995 builds it,
994 reads it.
Closes the gaps that kept ww_ww from rebuilding the wwstage byte-
for-byte. The pre-existing parser silently produced a broken AST
on `a, b = fn();` (a no-op exprstmt + a single assign that lost
the second tuple slot); the cgen leaned on a handful of cases
that the surface type-walker didn't yet cover, so 6a/6l/ww built
through wwstage drifted by a handful of bytes per file.
Parser:
- Multi-assign in parsestmt mirrors cmd/wwc/parse.c:1015-1031. If
parseexpr is followed by `,`, switch into N_MASSIGN: collect
the chained lvalues with parsebin(parseunary, 1) so they don't
eat the trailing `=`, then absorb `= rhs;` and emit the node.
Cgen:
- N_MASSIGN handler stores AX into l0's slot, pops DX into l1's
slot. Same shape as cmd/6c/cgen.c:2424-2440. Lvalues beyond
two are dropped (C drops them too).
- N_INDEX added to node_isunsigned: `p[i]` where p is *u8/[]u8/
[N]u8 now flags unsigned, so `p[i] >= 48u8` emits JAE instead
of JGE. Bit 6a's parsenum.
- node_isstr's N_DOT branch now handles chained dots via
dot_inner_struct_ptr, so `p.to.asym` (Adr.asym is str) flags
as str and push_args_rev pushes both halves.
- index_base_esz returns 1 for str-typed struct fields. Was
defaulting to 8, so `node.s[i]` scaled by 8 and used MOVQ
instead of MOVZBQ. Bit ww/visit_seen.
- N_LET with no initializer zero-inits the slot when the
underlying type is an 8-byte primitive (pointer, fn-ptr,
i64/u64, ...) — matches cmd/6c/cgen.c:2181. Structs,
strings, slices, etc. are left for per-field writes, even
when their slot rounds up to 8 in scan_locals. New helper
type_is_8byte_primitive walks the type AST to make the
same call C's checker would.
Tests stay 17/17; new self-rebuild test (995) lands in the next
commit and gates on these fixes.
build_one now invokes 6c_ww / 6a_ww / 6l_ww from $self_dir, not
the C-built binaries that share the directory. After this change
`ww_ww build foo.ww` touches no cstage code at runtime — the
fresh-checkout cstage is still needed to bring the wwstage into
existence, but day-to-day work runs on the ww toolchain end to
end. The C `ww` driver in cmd/ww/ still drives the C 6c/6a/6l.
Test 993 (which used to be trivial — both drivers invoked the
same C tools) now meaningfully compares the cstage pipeline
against the wwstage pipeline on hello + wwdump and confirms
byte-identical exes.
The .combined.ww files for 6a/6l/ww/wwdump and smoke are
regenerated by the ww driver's `expand()` step; their diff is
the lib/os dup2 wrapper and the cgen.ww port from the prior two
commits, propagating into the bootstrap inputs.
selfhost/cmd/6c/main.ww is a thin packaging of the wwc cgen — slurp
a .ww file, run lex+parse+cgen, write Plan 9 amd64 asm to the path
given by -o. The cgen routines in selfhost/cmd/wwc/cgen.ww write
directly to fd 1, so we use dup2 to redirect stdout into the
output file rather than thread an fd through every emit helper.
Adds the SYS_DUP2=33 wrapper in lib/os.
Makefile wires $(BIN)/6c_ww alongside the other wwstage tools and
adds $(BIN)/test_6c_ww to the TESTS list.
test/wwc/994_6c_ww.c diffs 6c_ww byte-for-byte against
`wwdump_ww -c` on five in-source programs plus the four selfhost
main.combined.ww files: same cgen reached through two binaries, so
any divergence is a packaging bug in selfhost/cmd/6c.
We deliberately don't diff against C-side 6c here — 990 probe 5
already covers that on the subset the ww cgen handles today.
Closes the byte-identity gap between selfhost/cmd/wwc/cgen.ww and
the C cgen, so a ww_ww-built binary matches the cstage-built binary
on the same input. The bootstrap fixed point was already green;
these are the bytes inside that fixed point that diverged from
what cmd/6c emits.
Slot allocation:
- local_add dedups by name (mirror cmd/6c/cgen.c:localoff). Two
`let cp: pos;` in disjoint if-branches share one slot. The
stored tnode is refreshed on each hit so a later `let m: *node`
shadowing an earlier `let m: i32` sees its own type when
emitting `m.next` — without this the N_DOT cgen fell into the
SB-symbol fallback and the linker complained about undefined
`next`.
- scan_locals dedups at frame-size time to keep the prologue SUBQ
in sync. cgfn seeds c.locals with param-name stubs before the
scan so a body's `let <param-name>` reuses the param slot, then
resets c.locals before emission so real offsets get installed.
- local_alloc (no dedup) for N_MCASE bindings: C cgen handles a
match as an expression with by-value `locals`, so two separate
matches each get fresh slots for `v`/`e`.
Per-instruction matching:
- `return;` in a void fn zeros AX (C cgen falls through to
cgexpr_int(c, 0)).
- N_INTLIT prints i64 (signed), not u64. FNV-1a's offset basis
now prints as `$-3750763034362895579`, matching `$%lld`.
- *p = strexpr push order swapped to PUSH AX / PUSH BX → POP CX
/ POP AX (cgen.c:1033-1041).
Feature port from 635818e (the half that the wwdump corpus
actually exercises):
- N_IDENT used as a value with fn type now LEAQs through
ffi_resolve, so `let fp = some_ffi_fn;` emits the C symbol.
- N_CALL on a bare ident checks local_find_node first; a local
fn-pointer dispatches as `cgexpr(callee); CALL AX` instead of
`CALL ident(SB)`.
Tests 990 probe 6 and 994 are byte-identical on mem/err/tok/smoke
+ the four selfhost main.combined.ww files. Bootstrap still
ww2 == ww3.
