A struct-literal array fill sized a narrow-alias element off a bare
primsize(name): `type my32 = u32` gave primsize("my32")=0, so the
element width defaulted to 8 and a [3]my32 strode MOVQ -24/-16/-8 —
field n collided with arr[2] (kw1_101 run exit 1). cstage chases
my32->u32->4 (MOVL stride-4) at the twin sites and is runtime-correct;
this is a ww-only align-up, cs untouched.
Fix: a new aliasprimsize(c, nm) SSoT helper — primsize(nm), else an
aliaslookup-chase N_TNAME loop then primsize — and route the SIZE-use
primsize() family through it. The 7 c-bearing bare-no-chase size-use
sites are routed: cgen:993 (letemitsize), cgenstmt:1896 (cgarrlitfillbp),
cgenutil:1579 (elemsizeofc fallback)/1657+1665 (nodeprimwidth)/4791
(cgstructlitfill = the kw1_101 site), cgenexpr:6902 (cgcall vararg esz).
This is the rule-13 close-by-construction shape (one accessor for
"resolved primitive size"), not a per-site patch.
kw1_101 is the SOLE asm mover (byte-id NO->YES, run 1->0, MOVL
stride-4); every other routed site is latent/byte-neutral. Bootstrap:
all 5 combined units stay w6c==w6c_ww byte-identical. sizelint 0,
peellint 0, test-unit 296/296.
Scope fence (rob route-7-decline-6 ruling): three DESIGNED-exemption
sites carry inline primsize-ok annotations — elemsizeof :1475/:1499 and
paramfieldsize :3541 are structural (no-`c`, non-chasing) BY DESIGN;
their alias-chasing twin elemsizeofc is the routed :1579 leg. These are
the #109 peellint-whitelist seeds. Three further declines are already
correct chasing paths, not bare-no-chase bug shapes (typenodeprimresolved
:2026 / exprprimresolved :2063 are the chase machinery itself; cgassign
:7631 already chases via typenodeprimresolved, #11). The ~17 GUARD sites
(is-primitive dispatch) + the peellint finale are the committed #109
follow-on. Threading `c` into the structural sizers is dormant #110.
#101
The two ww-side gates from ken's B6-c3 STOP re-attribution
(.ai/ken-b6-oracle.md addendum): WWSTAGE was the alias-blind side at
exactly two cgenexpr.ww sites, both keyed on a bare name-keyed
structlookup that only holds struct-decl names, so an alias-NAMED
spelling missed and fell to the generic-but-runtime-correct route —
byte-divergent from the canonical dedicated shape cs pins post-B6-c3:
(1) `arr[i].f = v` indexed-elem struct-field STORE arm (the write
twin of the task-#8 READ arm, which already chases via tichase);
(2) `&p.f` ptr-field fallback in the TK_AMP N_DOT single-dot leg.
REVIEW AMENDMENT (reviewer-W2, rob's close-by-construction
obligation): the proof-sweep of the two arms found ONE same-class
survivor — (3) the value-struct `&x.f` leg, one leg below (2) in the
same single-DOT arm, same alias-blind bare structlookup. Probe
rW2_ampv reproduced the identical bit-proven mechanism (ww_alias !=
ww_plain; cs_alias == ww_plain) at both base and the frozen tip; the
other in-arm routes are clean (letvar* global helpers chase, str/len
pseudo-field alias legs are filed-loud #96, chained depth>=2 resolves
via tinfo). Same chase applied; arm survivor count is now zero by
the same grep+probe construction.
All three now resolve through structlookupchain (#22) — the name
layer's own alias-chain accessor (the cstage transitive-peel mirror),
already consumed by the sibling `p.f = v` assign arm and cgdot's
pointer-to-struct read. Plain rows short-circuit at its structlookup
head, so non-alias emission is byte-identical by construction; alias
rows land on the same structinfo as their plain twins, so the
dedicated emission converges bit-exactly. esz stays sound:
elemsizeofc reads the chased stamped tinfo (#8 leg).
Convergence proven with ken's pre-staged W2 instrument: ww_alias ==
ww_plain bit-IDENTICAL for kb6_idxf and kb6_ampf (cmp exit 0), which
also lands cs==ww byte-id on both rows; plain controls byte-id held
and their ww asm unchanged base->tip. Full ken-corpus matrix vs the
B6-tip baseline: movers are exactly {kb6_idxf, kb6_ampf} NO->YES;
detectors unmoved (kw1_101 cs0/ww1, fill2 both-loud, tuparg_c
cs0/ww1, fsarg2/fsarg0/try pinned texts verbatim, B5/B6 graduations
all byte-id). Zero behavioral change on any accepted program, zero
acceptance change in either direction.
ww-only: zero C-source bytes; cs binaries (w6c/ww/w6a/w6l) md5
bit-identical base->tip; w6c_ww + wwdump main.combined.ww regen'd via
make, idempotent. 989 lib ratchet: zero flips (31 byte-identical /
9 pinned-divergent #59 / 3 pinned-wwreject #59 across 43 units).
944_alias_cgen_b6_run: idxf_2lvl + ampf_2lvl graduate K_RUN_NOID ->
K_RUN (the two restored byte-id cells) — B6-c3's mutation teeth
restored (reviewer-B6 N-a closes); + amendment rows ampv_2lvl /
ampv_plain_ctl pin the third gate (checks 61 -> 69). All 9 944-family
suites green; sizelint 0; make test-unit "all 292 tests passed".
The exact B6-c5 set (rob b6 spec §2, numbering at 4cac1cb): :3820
(fn-symbol load u), :7201 (#235 len() tuple-elem bu), :7807
(type_default let-init region u), :7900 (append su, str→[]u8 region),
:9944 (`is` source u — the #37 memread predicate feed; the >32B cap
test now keys the CHASED size, mirroring ww's taggedmemread, per the
EYES condition — kb6_memread 40B-union byte-NEUTRALITY is the
regression net, held), :10224 (module-qualified value ref tu),
:10750/:10873 (tagged-union field loads, direct + through-ptr
tag_fu/ptag_fu). Raw `->under` in cgen.c 17→9 — the remaining 9 are
EXACTLY the designed whitelist survivors (:731 nullable_ptr_tag +
:813/:814 + :834/:835 cg_variant_match peel-ok-#218, #95's fold) and
B7's 4 emitter/intern lines (:14356 :14574 :14788 :15088). B6's 49
granted lines are fully retired; grep-verified.
FLIP: kb6_tfread (tagged-union field load direct + through-ptr over
alias struct, was both-correct divergent NO(4)) → 0/0 BYTE-ID; cs
converged onto ww's UNCHANGED asm (#263 polarity, cmp-proven) and the
alias shape equals the plain shape (kb6_tfread_p, same hash — ken's
c5 pre-test). kb6_len / kb6_gref / kb6_memread latent byte-NEUTRAL
as predicted.
TRAIN INVARIANT (held c1..tip): cs-only; w6c_ww/ww_ww bit-identical
to the 4cac1cb baselines (b6bddc8eb5c3ed8e805e50371d4b7017 /
4e9ca8741f19e1f68219ff799a5e5a14) at all five boundaries. cs movers
c4→c5 bounded to exactly {kb6_tfread}; rest of corpus + five mains
byte-NEUTRAL; kw1_101/fill2/tuparg_c/xampdef/amplen1 detectors
unmoved across the whole train; 989 ratchet zero flips.
944_alias_cgen_b6_run final table: 18→22 rows, 49→61 checks
(tfread_2lvl flip + len_2lvl/gref_2lvl controls + memread_40b cap-
watch pin). All 944-family suites green; sizelint 0.
The exact B6-c4 set (rob b6 spec §2, numbering at 4cac1cb): :9422
(N_MATCH Family-C identity-cast peel su), :9598 (match-bind base bu),
:9674 (tryprop non-call source u), :9718 (cg_ret_type peel r at the
cgexpr try region — same rt-route kinship as B5-c3's cgreturn chase:
the nullable/tagged propagate keys the chased enclosing return type
exactly as the return arms do), :9819 (tryunw twin u — LOUD-PRESERVING
ONLY, the #38b sret bound is alias-INDEPENDENT), :9986/:9991
(N_TYPEASSERT u + enum vu), :10103/:10105 (str→[]u8 cap-synth tu/fu),
:10131 (narrowing-cast tu). Raw `->under` in cgen.c 27→17 — remaining
= whitelist 5 (:731 :813/:814 :834/:835) + B7 emitters 4 + the c5
set 8, grep-verified exact.
FLIP: kb6_strcast (str→[]u8 over 2-level alias, was both-correct
divergent NO(2)) → 0/0 BYTE-ID; cs converged onto ww's UNCHANGED asm
(#263 polarity, cmp-proven) and the alias shape now equals the plain
shape (kb6_strcast_p, same hash — ken's c4 pre-test confirmed ww's
dedicated gate DOES fire on alias here, unlike the c3 sites).
kb6_try loud held both stages with the pinned #38b text (try_loud_38b
row); idcast/is/succ byte-id held; zero other movers.
TRAIN INVARIANT: cs-only; w6c_ww/ww_ww bit-identical to the 4cac1cb
baselines (b6bddc8e…/4e9ca874…). cs movers c3→c4 bounded to exactly
{kb6_strcast}; rest of corpus + five mains byte-NEUTRAL; detectors
unmoved; 989 ratchet zero flips.
944_alias_cgen_b6_run grows 14→18 rows, 38→49 checks: strcast_2lvl
flip + idcast_2lvl/is_2lvl controls + try_loud_38b both-loud pin.
All 944-family suites green; sizelint 0.
The exact B6-c3 set (rob b6 spec §2, numbering at 4cac1cb): :3949
(&ident classify ou), :4006 (&mod.G leaf lu), :4124/:4128 (&p.f
ptr-field fallback bu/inner), :5029/:5035/:5052 (indexed-elem
struct-field STORE elemu/inner/bu), :5937 (assign-region esub peel),
:10953/:10956 (chained N_DOT ptr lu/inner), :11046/:11052/:11067
(indexed-elem struct-field READ twin), :11285 (index-region esub peel
— gates key the chased esubu exactly as the ident arm, per the EYES
condition). Raw `->under` in cgen.c 41→27.
RE-ATTRIBUTION (ken c3-STOP addendum, adjudicated on his independent
scratch build): kb6_idxf and kb6_ampf did NOT land on the oracle's
predicted post-states — and the train direction is CORRECT anyway.
Bit-proven mechanism: post-chase cs_alias asm == ww_PLAIN (the
byte-id-gate-proven canonical dedicated shape) for BOTH rows; it is
WWSTAGE that is alias-blind at these two sites (ww_alias != ww_plain
— its indexed-elem struct-field store/read gates and the &p.f
ptr-field fallback don't fire on alias bases and fall to generic-but-
runtime-correct routes). Converging cs onto ww_alias would re-blind
cs — canonical is the convergence target. ampf's pre-c3 byte-id was
both-stages-on-the-generic-route identity (gate-blind, #263-class),
NOT M5 latency — oracle self-correction banked. Both rows pinned
K_RUN_NOID (cs-0 + ww-0, byte-id waived) + plain-control rows pin the
convergence target; they graduate to full byte-id when the filed
ww-side W2 fold (task #102) lands (ww gate chase; kw1/#100/W1 precedent; zero
metric-1 content). chdot/esub byte-NEUTRAL bound held.
TRAIN INVARIANT: cs-only; w6c_ww/ww_ww bit-identical to the 4cac1cb
baselines (b6bddc8e…/4e9ca874…). cs movers c2→c3 bounded to exactly
{kb6_idxf, kb6_ampf} — the named c3 family; both run-cells ok/0 held;
rest of corpus + five mains byte-NEUTRAL; detectors unmoved; 989
ratchet zero flips.
944_alias_cgen_b6_run grows 8→14 rows, 22→38 checks: idxf_2lvl/
ampf_2lvl NOID pins + idxf_plain_ctl/ampf_plain_ctl canonical-shape
pins + chdot_2lvl/esub_2lvl controls. All 944-family suites green;
sizelint 0.
The exact B6-c2 set (rob b6 spec §2): :8402 (callee fn-type resolve cu),
:8435 (variadic slice param vsu), :8561/:8563 + :8577/:8579 (tagged
widen-detect pu/au pairs, arg-class + #38b MEMORY-class) + the two
LOUD-PRESERVING chases :8829 (float-struct rule-7 fatal st) and :8934
(#32 tuple-arg rule-7 fatal targ). Raw `->under` in cgen.c 49→41.
LOUD-PRESERVING discipline: the :8829/:8934 chases widen what the gate
SEES, never what it ACCEPTS. DESIGNED ACCEPTANCE NARROWING (ken b6
oracle c2): kb6_fsarg2 — a 1-level-alias float-struct from a non-ident
source previously DODGED the #271/#165 fatal via the single peel; cs
accepted and GP-passed it runtime-correct by self-consistent luck
(caller+callee agreed on the wrong transport, no SSE eightbyte). Post-
c2 cs louds with the pinned #271/#165 text. ww's cell was already loud
at its own alias-return bound (#272/#276/#277 class) — fsarg2_bound
pins BOTH texts per-stage (experr_ww). fsarg0 plain control stays loud
both stages. :8934 is WATCH-ONLY (alias tuple-args are checker-blocked
upstream, #86/#99): kb5_tuparg_c two-key cells verified unmoved
(cs ok/0 + ww ok/1).
TRAIN INVARIANT: cs-only; w6c_ww/ww_ww bit-identical to the 4cac1cb
baselines (b6bddc8e…/4e9ca874…). cs movers bounded to exactly
kb6_fsarg2 (run-cell ok/0→ERR, no asm emitted — zero run-row movers);
rest of the corpus + five mains byte-NEUTRAL; kw1_101/fill2/tuparg_c/
xampdef/amplen1 detectors unmoved; 989 ratchet zero flips. kb6_sarg /
kb6_strarg / kb6_fsarg (ident twin) latent byte-NEUTRAL per ken's
structural bound.
944_alias_cgen_b6_run grows 3→8 rows, 9→22 checks: fsarg0_loud_ctl +
fsarg2_bound (per-stage experr pins; row struct gains experr_ww for
two-site loud pairs) + fsarg_ident_ctl/sarg_2lvl/strarg_2lvl controls.
All 944-family suites green; sizelint 0.
The exact B6-c1 set (rob b6 spec §2): cgexpr :6359 (tagged-local plain
reassign lu), :6403/:6405 (deref-target assign pu/vt), :6460/:6462
(deref compound-assign pu/vt), :6518 (str/slice/struct reassign lu) +
cgstmt :11696 (nomem null-propagate r), :12047 (assign base peel bu),
:13625 (destructure-reassign rhs ru — chased; the #64 citation above it
stays, the deferral is about the tuple-literal rhs ROUTE, not this
peel). Raw `->under` in cgen.c 58→49.
TRAIN INVARIANT: cs-only — zero selfhost/ or lib/ bytes move; w6c_ww/
ww_ww bit-identical to ken's 4cac1cb baselines (md5
b6bddc8eb5c3ed8e805e50371d4b7017 / 4e9ca8741f19e1f68219ff799a5e5a14).
cs movers bounded to exactly: kb6_streassign, kb5_wstore_a (the
named c1 family); the rest of the kb4/kb5/kb6/kna corpus + five
selfhost mains byte-NEUTRAL both stages; kw1_101 / fill2 / tuparg_c /
xampdef / amplen1 detectors unmoved. 989 lib ratchet: zero flips.
LIVE graduation: kb6_streassign (the :6518 lu single-peel missed
TY_STR at 2 alias levels, fell to the scalar default — `b = a` copied
the ptr WORD0 only, len/cap stale, cs silent exit 1; ww was the
runtime-correct full 3-word reference) → 0/0 byte-id. Designed
graduation: kb5_wstore_a (ken C1-CORR-2 seed — the ident-lhs N_ASSIGN
tagged gate :6359 is cgexpr INLINE, never reached B5's :2456 funnel)
→ wstore_a_2lvl re-pinned K_RUN_NOID→K_RUN in the b5 suite (84→85
checks). kb6_sreassign / kb6_dassign latent controls byte-NEUTRAL as
ken's structural bound predicts.
New 944_alias_cgen_b6_run row table (3 rows, 9 checks): streassign_2lvl
+ sreassign_2lvl/dassign_2lvl controls; Makefile wires
test_alias_cgen_b6_run into the unit list. All 944-family suites green;
sizelint 0.
